Chicken Alley, Vineyard Haven

Thrifting Treasures: Where to Find Great Deals on Martha’s Vineyard

On Martha’s Vineyard, shopping doesn’t always mean luxury boutiques and resort prices. Beyond the charming storefronts and seaside markets, there’s a vibrant world of thrift and bargain stores waiting to be explored. Whether you’re hunting for a unique souvenir, outfitting your summer home, or looking to score a great deal, the Island’s secondhand shops offer an eco-friendly and budget-conscious way to experience Vineyard style.

From high-end consignment finds to hidden gems tucked away in small-town corners, here’s where to find great discounts and thrifted treasures across the Island.

Chicken Alley Thrift Shop (Vineyard Haven)

A cornerstone of Island thrifting, Chicken Alley Thrift Shop is legendary among locals. Run by Martha’s Vineyard Community Services, it’s the place where you might find anything from vintage Vineyard memorabilia to a gently worn Patagonia jacket or a mid-century lamp.

What sets Chicken Alley apart is its personality. The shop has an ever-changing inventory, community-driven atmosphere, and an unmistakable Island spirit. Every summer, it hosts the famous “Art & Collectibles Sale,” where Island artists and collectors donate pieces, turning the store into a pop-up gallery of treasures.

Shopping here feels like stepping into an Island story; one where sustainability, creativity, and community all come together.

Frankie’s Revival (Vineyard Haven)

One of the newest and most exciting additions to the Island’s thrift scene is Frankie’s Revival in Vineyard Haven. Opened in 2024, this thoughtfully curated secondhand store has already become a local favorite. Frankie’s Revival brings new life to pre-loved clothing, accessories, and home décor, offering a blend of modern style and nostalgic charm.

What makes Frankie’s Revival stand out is its attention to detail: each item feels handpicked, creating an experience that feels more like boutique shopping than thrifting. You’ll find designer pieces, everyday essentials, and Island-inspired styles, all with sustainable shopping in mind.

Second Treasures Thrift Shop (Oak Bluffs)

For those who love a good hunt, Second Treasures MV in Oak Bluffs is a must-visit. This local favorite offers a wide range of gently used items, from clothing and accessories to home goods and furniture. With affordable prices and frequent new arrivals, it’s easy to walk out with a bag full of bargains.

The shop is also a reflection of the Island’s eclectic charm: where nautical finds meet bohemian styles, and every corner holds something unexpected. It’s the perfect stop before a stroll around Oak Bluffs’ iconic gingerbread cottages or a walk along the harbor.

ACT Two, Vineyard Haven

ACT Two (Vineyard Haven)

If you’re looking for thrift shopping with a touch of purpose, ACT Two is a standout. This nonprofit resale boutique offers a carefully curated selection of clothing, accessories, and home décor, with proceeds supporting arts and theatre programs for children across the Island and in local public schools.

ACT Two is known for its quality inventory and community spirit. Shoppers often find designer labels and one-of-a-kind pieces while helping to nurture the Island’s creative youth. It’s a true win-win for fashion lovers and philanthropists alike.

Why Thrifting on Martha’s Vineyard Is Worth the Hunt

Thrifting on Martha’s Vineyard isn’t just about scoring deals; it’s about discovery. Each shop reflects the Island’s unique blend of coastal charm, artistic energy, and community connection. You’ll find beachy boho pieces, timeless New England classics, and treasures that tell a story of Island life.

Plus, thrifting supports sustainability and local causes, making your purchases feel even better. Many of these stores donate proceeds to essential Island services or nonprofits, helping to keep the community thriving year-round.

So next time you visit the Island, explore its secondhand scene instead. You never know what hidden gems you might uncover or whose life you might brighten with your purchase.