Sweet Spots: Discover Martha’s Vineyard’s Best Bakeries and Treats
Back Door Donuts
There’s something about Martha’s Vineyard that makes everything taste a little sweeter. Maybe it’s the salty air mingling with the scent of freshly baked bread, or the leisurely pace that invites you to savor every bite. Whether you’re craving a morning muffin, an afternoon cookie, or a dessert to cap off a perfect Island day, Martha’s Vineyard offers a delightful array of bakeries and sweet shops that deliver both flavor and charm. From cozy cafés to local bakeries tucked into quiet corners of the Island towns, each brings something special to the Island’s culinary scene.
Here’s a guide to some of the most beloved bakeries and sweet spots on Martha’s Vineyard, organized by town.
Vineyard Haven: Classic Comforts and Fresh Creations
Vineyard Haven blends tradition with creativity in its bakery scene. A few favorites have earned loyal followings among locals and visitors alike.
Scottish Bakehouse has been an Island staple for decades. Known for its farm-to-table approach, the bakery offers hearty breads, muffins, cookies, and pastries made from scratch, using locally sourced ingredients whenever possible. Their coconut macaroons, assorted cookies and scones are must-tries, and breakfast sandwiches remain a local favorite.
Pie Chicks is a beloved stop for handmade pies crafted with simple, high-quality ingredients. Seasonal fruit pies like blueberry and peach sit alongside year-round favorites such as chocolate cream and key lime. The bakery also offers quiches, cookies, and savory hand pies, perfect for a quick snack or picnic on the go.
Sweet Bites combines Brazilian flair with Island hospitality. Known for Brazilian-inspired pastries like brigadeiros and decadent cakes, Sweet Bites also serves excellent espresso and light breakfast and lunch options. Don’t miss their offerings, a delicious choice in Vineyard Haven!
Black Dog Bakery & Café is a local favorite that pairs freshly baked goods with a cozy, welcoming atmosphere. Known for its homemade breads, muffins, and pastries, the café also offers hearty breakfast options, sandwiches, and coffee. It’s a perfect spot to linger over a morning pastry or grab a treat before heading out to explore the town.
Delicious MV, located on Main Street, is a must-visit for anyone with a sweet tooth. This bakery and dessert shop specializes in beautifully crafted cookies and seasonal treats that are as stunning as they are delicious. With a focus on premium ingredients and elegant presentation, Delicious MV is perfect for picking up a special dessert, a box of assorted sweets, or a custom creation for any Island celebration.
Quitsa Kitchen adds to Vineyard Haven’s culinary charm, offering thoughtfully made baked goods that celebrate Island flavors and creativity. It’s a wonderful stop for anyone exploring the town’s artisan food scene.
Oak Bluffs: A Blend of Nostalgia and Indulgence
Oak Bluffs is a town where fun and flavor go hand in hand, and its bakeries capture that same cheerful energy.
Back Door Donuts is an Island legend. For decades, visitors have lined up after dark for warm, sugary donuts straight from the fryer. From classic apple fritters to maple bacon and Boston cream, these treats have become a summer-night tradition. Even if the line stretches down the street, the sweet reward is always worth the wait.
Ben & Bill’s Chocolate Emporium offers further indulgences with ice cream, fudge, and handcrafted chocolates. Their Island-made ice creams range from classic flavors like mint chip to adventurous options such as lobster ice cream—a novelty worth trying at least once.
Mo’s Lunch, tucked inside the OB Arts District, is another delicious addition to the town’s food scene. Known for its creative, comforting meals, it’s also home to baker Korilee, who makes some of the Island’s best cookies, cakes, and sweet treats. It’s a hidden gem for anyone with a sweet tooth.
Mocha Mott’s Coffee Shop rounds out Oak Bluffs' sweet offerings. Muffins, bagels, and cookies pair perfectly with a locally roasted cup of coffee. It’s a relaxed, community-minded spot, ideal for a quick morning bite before catching the ferry or strolling Circuit Ave.
Edgartown: Elegant Pastries and Coastal Charm
Edgartown’s bakeries mirror the town’s refined yet relaxed vibe, offering sweets that pair beautifully with boutique shopping or a harbor-side stroll.
Rosewater Market & Takeaway brings community and craftsmanship together. Their pastry case is always filled with muffins, loaf cakes, cookies, and bars, highlighting quality ingredients and expert technique.
Espresso Love continues to be a go-to spot for its extensive selection of baked goods. From flaky scones to decadent brownies, there’s something for every craving. Smoothies, salads, and sandwiches also make it an easy stop for travelers refueling before exploring the town.
Morning Glory Farm is a must for its freshly baked zucchini bread, sourdough loaves, cookies, and more—all made with seasonal Island ingredients. The aroma alone is enough to draw you in on your way into town.
Black Sheep offers both savory and sweet temptations. Their cupcakes and croissants are standouts, making it a great stop for breakfast or an afternoon pick-me-up.
Iggy’s Bread brings its signature breads and treats to the Island, offering everything from hearty loaves to cookies and pastries that perfectly complement your morning coffee or picnic lunch.
Edgartown Meat and Fish Market may be known for its high-quality meats and seafood, but locals also flock there for its fresh bagels and irresistible donuts—a morning staple for many Islanders.
Behind the Bookstore, just steps from Edgartown Books, is a seasonal café (open during warmer months) serving artisan coffee, croissants, tarts, cookies, and other treats that are delicious.
Morning Glory Farm
West Tisbury: Rustic, Homemade Goodness
In West Tisbury, baking leans toward rustic and homespun, celebrating simplicity and local ingredients.
7a Foods is a beloved local spot where nearly everything is made from scratch. Cookies, muffins, pastries, and brownies draw a loyal following. It’s also a great place to pick up a hearty sandwich or picnic provisions before heading to Lambert’s Cove Beach or exploring scenic up-Island trails.
Chilmark and Aquinnah: Artisanal Baking with a View
Up-Island, baked goods come with an extra helping of natural beauty.
Orange Peel Bakery in Aquinnah is as much a community gathering place as it is a bakery. Founded by Island baker Juli Vanderhoop, this outdoor, wood-fired bakery serves fresh baguettes, focaccia, cookies, fruit galettes, and pizzas. The aroma of wood smoke and fresh bread fills the air, creating a warm, welcoming atmosphere that feels quintessentially Martha’s Vineyard. It’s a must-visit for anyone exploring the western end of the Island.
A Sweet Tradition
Exploring Martha’s Vineyard through its bakeries is about more than satisfying a craving. It’s a window into the Island’s culture, one that values community, creativity, and the simple joy of sharing good food. Whether sipping coffee in Vineyard Haven, waiting for warm donuts in Oak Bluffs, or savoring a rustic tart in Aquinnah, every bite connects you to the spirit of the Island.
From flaky pastries to homemade pies, Martha’s Vineyard’s bakeries remind us that sweetness is best enjoyed slowly, in good company, and with a view of the sea nearby.