24 Hours in Edgartown: How to Spend a Perfect Day
Edgartown Lighthouse, photo by Marnely Murray
If you have only one day to spend on Martha’s Vineyard, Edgartown is a wonderful place to explore. Known for its elegant charm, whaling-era history, and seaside beauty, this town is one of the most picturesque on the Island. With historic captains’ houses, boutique shops, beautiful beaches, and a lively dining scene, Edgartown offers the perfect balance of relaxation and adventure.
To get here, you can take the Falmouth Ferry, which runs seasonally, or arrive year-round via the Steamship Authority Ferry into Vineyard Haven or Oak Bluffs (seasonal as well). From either town, hop on the Vineyard Transit Authority bus for a quick and affordable ride into Edgartown. The bus station drops you off right in the center of town, within walking distance to shops, restaurants, and the harbor. Taxis and bike rentals are also available if you prefer. Once you arrive, get ready for a full day of food, fun, and discovery.
Among the Flowers in Edgartown
Morning: Coffee, Breakfast, and a Stroll
Start your day with a hearty Island breakfast.
- Among the Flowers Café: A cozy favorite where you can enjoy delicious waffles in a charming garden setting.
- Dock Street Coffee Shop: A classic diner-style spot where locals gather. Order the Port Mac breakfast sandwich with Portuguese sausage.
- Lucky Hank’s: A popular choice for their fish cakes with eggs and crispy home fries.
- Morning Glory Farm: If you prefer something lighter, stop by for freshly baked muffins or scones along with a cup of hot coffee.
Morning Glory Farm, photo by Marnely Murray
- Behind the Bookstore Café: A tucked-away gem offering excellent coffee, pastries, and light bites in a lovely outdoor courtyard.
- Rosewater Café: A neighborhood favorite with delicious breakfast sandwiches, avocado toast, and excellent coffee.
- Espresso Love: Known for its baked goods and sandwiches, this spot is great for grabbing breakfast to-go before a day of exploring.
After breakfast, take a walk through town to soak in the historic New England architecture. White clapboard homes with black shutters and lush hydrangeas line the streets, each one telling a story of Edgartown’s past as a whaling capital.
Edgartown Town Hall, photo by Marnely Murray
Midday: History, Views, and Shopping
Make your way to the Edgartown Lighthouse, one of the most iconic sights on the Island. From the top, you’ll be rewarded with sweeping views of the harbor and Chappaquiddick. The short walk to the lighthouse along the sandy path is as memorable as the view itself.
While in town, stop by the Carnegie and the Old Whaling Church, both beautifully preserved by the Vineyard Preservation Trust. The Carnegie now serves as a heritage center, showcasing exhibits about the Island’s history, while the Old Whaling Church is a striking Greek Revival landmark that often hosts cultural events and performances.
Next, wander down Main Street in Edgartown, where you’ll find an excellent variety of shops and galleries.
- CB Stark Jewelers: A Vineyard classic, this jeweler has been creating timeless Island-inspired pieces for decades.
- Edgartown Books: A must-stop for readers. This independent bookstore also has a cozy café in the back where you can sip coffee while browsing for your next beach read.
- The Black Dog General Store: A Vineyard staple and a great place to pick up a souvenir.
- Salte: A boutique with a modern, coastal aesthetic featuring home goods and gifts.
- Nell: A chic shop with clothing and accessories perfect for Island style.
- Backwater Trading Company: Offering unique gifts, apparel, and Island-inspired goods.
- Katydid: Known for stylish women’s clothing and accessories.
- Vineyard Vines: A nationally known brand that began on Martha’s Vineyard and continues to capture classic coastal living.
- Portobello Road: For art, antiques, and one-of-a-kind treasures.
Take your time browsing, and enjoy the charming streets that make Edgartown such a unique destination.
Old Sculpin Gallery
Afternoon: Beaches, Galleries, and Island Views
After exploring downtown, you may be ready to relax by the water. Fuller Street Beach is just a short walk from town and perfect for a quick swim or sandy stroll. For something more adventurous, consider renting a bike and pedaling out to South Beach, one of the Island’s most famous stretches of shoreline with powerful surf and wide sandy dunes.
If you’re a movie buff, book an Amity Tour to see filming locations from Jaws, which was largely shot around Edgartown. It’s a fun way to combine Island history with a bit of Hollywood nostalgia.
Edgartown is also home to several outstanding art galleries worth exploring in the afternoon:
- Old Sculpin Gallery: Housed in a historic building near the harbor, this gallery showcases works from the Martha’s Vineyard Art Association.
- Eisenhauer Gallery: A vibrant collection of contemporary paintings, sculpture, and jewelry.
- North Water Gallery: Featuring a wide range of fine art, from traditional seascapes to modern works.
These galleries highlight the Island’s creative spirit and make for a lovely cultural break between shopping and beach time.
Evening: Dinner and Drinks
Edgartown has no shortage of incredible dining options to close out your day. Depending on your style, here are a few highlights:
- Bettini at the Harbor View Hotel: An upscale dining experience offering refined coastal cuisine with sweeping views of the Edgartown Lighthouse.
- The Wharf Pub: A casual spot loved by locals and visitors alike. Order a bowl of clam chowder or a stuffed quahog, and pair it with a local beer.
- Detenté: A hidden gem tucked away in Nevin Square. This intimate restaurant is ideal for a romantic or special occasion dinner, with creative dishes that highlight seasonal ingredients.
- Rockfish: A stylish two-level restaurant with wood-fired pizzas, small plates, and creative cocktails.
- TownMV: Known for fun, modern cuisine and a lively bar scene, it’s a great option for groups.
- Seafood Shanty: A casual harborside spot with sushi, seafood platters, and rooftop views of the water.
- 19 Raw Oyster Bar: Perfect for oyster lovers and seafood enthusiasts, with a raw bar and fresh daily specials.
- Newes from America Pub: This cozy pub serves hearty fare and a great selection of beers.
- Atlantic Fish and Chop House: Lively and right on the harbor, this restaurant is a favorite for seafood, steak, and a fun evening atmosphere. Their lobster macaroni and cheese is a standout dish.
If you still have time before your ferry, stop by Mad Martha’s Ice Cream for a scoop of homemade ice cream to end your visit on a sweet note.