Where to Find Delicious Burgers on Martha’s Vineyard: A Local’s Guide to Juicy Bites on the Island
The Attic (photo: Marnely Murray)
When it comes to dining on Martha’s Vineyard, seafood often takes center stage, but the Island’s burger scene deserves just as much attention. Whether you're craving a perfectly charred classic cheeseburger, a gourmet patty topped with inventive ingredients, or a satisfying plant-based alternative, Martha’s Vineyard delivers. The Island’s restaurants take pride in sourcing fresh, local ingredients and crafting menus that appeal to every palate. From seaside shacks to upscale eateries, this guide shares the best places to find a delicious burger on Martha’s Vineyard.
What Makes Martha’s Vineyard Burgers so Special
The tastiest burgers on Martha’s Vineyard go beyond basic. Many restaurants feature Island-raised beef, locally baked buns, farm-fresh produce, and house-made sauces. Some spots cater to traditionalists, offering classic American cheeseburgers done right, while others experiment with toppings like caramelized onions, maple bacon, artisan cheeses, and aioli. The result is a burger scene as diverse and flavorful as the Island itself.
Whether you’re visiting for a weekend or spending the entire summer, here are the top burger joints worth seeking out.
Burgers in Edgartown
Rockfish
This two-story restaurant on North Water Street delivers casual sophistication and a strong burger lineup. Rockfish offers not one, but three burger options: a classic cheeseburger, a surf-and-turf burger topped with buttery lobster meat, and a rotating chef’s special burger. Pair one with their truffle fries or a craft cocktail for a memorable dinner downtown.
Located just outside downtown Edgartown, Town MV is a lively gathering place that blends upscale pub food with a laid-back setting. Their House Burger features a thick, flavorful beef patty topped with cheddar, lettuce, tomato, and their signature house sauce on a brioche bun. It’s served with hand-cut fries and pairs well with their rotating local beers on tap. For plant-based eaters, Town also offers an Impossible Burger option.
Wicked Burger
Located in Edgartown, Wicked Burger brings a bold, fast-casual energy to the Island’s burger scene. Known for its crispy-edged smash burgers and flavorful toppings like bacon, pickled jalapeños, and house-made sauces, this spot is perfect for diners looking for a satisfying, customizable bite in a modern setting.
The Newes from America
Nestled in the heart of Edgartown, The Newes offers a cozy pub atmosphere in a historic brick building. Their house burger is a reliable favorite, served with classic toppings and thick-cut fries. With its colonial charm and hearty menu, The Newes serves up a satisfying meal in a warm, laid-back atmosphere.
Alchemy
Alchemy in Edgartown blends upscale dining with Island comfort. Their Wagyu burger is topped with Vermont cheddar and served on a housemade bun with a side of fries, offering a refined take on a beloved classic in a relaxed yet elegant setting.
Atria
Atria’s Brick Cellar Bar in Edgartown is a popular spot for creative burgers served in a lively, upscale tavern setting. The menu often features rotating specials alongside a few classics, all crafted with house-ground beef and premium toppings. It’s a great choice for a burger night with a little extra flair.
Atlantic Fish & Chophouse
Located along Edgartown Harbor, Atlantic Fish & Chophouse offers a stunning waterfront setting and a standout burger. The “Atlantic Burger” is a flavorful Cajun-seasoned patty topped with feta tzatziki, fennel, and arugula, an upscale twist that’s both bold and refreshing. It’s the perfect pairing for a sunset dinner after a day exploring Edgartown.
The Port Hunter
A popular downtown hotspot, The Port Hunter is known for its lively atmosphere and locally inspired dishes. Their “PH Burger” is juicy, satisfying, and served with hand-cut fries, making it one of the top go-to comfort meals in town. The menu rotates seasonally, but the PH Burger remains a reliable classic.
Katama Kitchen
Located just a short ride from South Beach, Katama Kitchen serves breakfast, lunch, and dinner with a casual coastal vibe. Their lunch menu includes two burger options: a beef smash burger and a vegan smash burger, both of which can be customized with toppings like cheese, bacon, or pickles. It’s a versatile spot for a laid-back and satisfying meal.
Fat Ronnies (photo: Steve Myrick)
Burger Spots in Oak Bluffs
Fat Ronnie’s Burger Bar
One of the most beloved burger joints on the Island, Fat Ronnie’s Burger Bar is all about customizable, made-to-order burgers. Located right on Circuit Avenue, this fast-casual favorite allows diners to choose from beef, turkey, or veggie patties and build their dream burger. With an array of sauces, toppings, and sides, it’s a must-visit for burger purists and creatives alike.
Lookout Tavern
Lookout Tavern boasts stunning ocean views—and an equally impressive burger menu. Options include a classic cheeseburger, a hearty patty melt, a surf and turf burger topped with lobster meat, and the owner’s special: a decadent burger topped with Boursin cheese, a fried egg, and capers. Pair it with a cold beer and enjoy the bustling harbor atmosphere.
Lookout Tavern (photo: Diane Alter)
Offshore Ale Company
A staple brewpub on Kennebec Avenue, Offshore Ale Company serves up a classic burger and a turkey burger, each made with care and best enjoyed with a pint of their house-crafted beer. Add an order of truffle fries on the side for an elevated take on this casual favorite.
The Barn Bowl & Bistro
A casual dining destination with a family-friendly vibe, The Barn serves a classic cheeseburger and a plant-based Beyond Burger. Located just outside the main downtown area, it’s a great option for groups or a fun dinner after bowling a few frames.
Nomans
Nomans is known for its laid-back vibe, lawn games, and live music—but don’t overlook the food. Their classic burger is served on a soft potato bun with a side of house-made special sauce. Grab a picnic table, order a round of drinks, and enjoy a relaxed Island evening with a burger in hand.
Martha’s Vineyard Chowder Company
Known for its award-winning chowder, this Circuit Avenue favorite also impresses with its inventive “Rangoon Burger.” This standout features a beef patty topped with crispy crab rangoons, pineapple salsa, leaf lettuce, and a sweet chili drizzle. It’s a creative fusion that delivers big flavor in every bite.
Black Dog Tavern (photo: Marnely Murray)
Burgers in Vineyard Haven
The Attic
Located above Waterside Market, The Attic serves up some of the most creative and crave-worthy burgers on the Island. Their smash burger is a crowd favorite, with crispy edges and melty cheese, while the Firehouse Burger kicks things up with bold spices and heat. With a variety of burger styles on the menu, this spot delivers for carnivores and foodies alike.
The Black Dog Tavern
An Island institution, The Black Dog Tavern serves hearty, satisfying meals year-round. Their burger is a classic: thick beef patty, cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato, and onion on a fresh bun, served with fries or chips. With views of the Vineyard Haven Harbor and nautical charm, this is a quintessential Island experience.
Bobby B’s Restaurant and Bakery
Located on Main Street in Vineyard Haven, Bobby B’s offers two flavorful beef options worth seeking out: the BBQ Beef Burger, smothered in smoky sauce and crispy onions, and the Buffalo Beef Burger, which adds heat and tang with buffalo seasoning and blue cheese dressing. Both are satisfying, well-prepared, and perfect for a casual meal.
Vegan and Veggie Burger Options
Martha’s Vineyard has embraced the plant-based trend, and there are plenty of options for those looking for meat-free alternatives.
- Fat Ronnie’s, The Barn Bowl & Bistro, and Town Bar & Grill all offer Beyond or Impossible burgers.
- Pawnee House in Oak Bluffs serves a flavorful falafel burger, perfect for those seeking a Mediterranean-inspired alternative to traditional veggie patties.
- Rosewater Market in downtown Edgartown focuses on fresh, wholesome ingredients, and its veggie burger is no exception. Made with a blend of black beans, quinoa, and sweet potatoes, and topped with pickled onions and house-made aioli, it’s a flavorful and satisfying option for plant-based eaters.
Many restaurants are happy to accommodate dietary needs with gluten-free buns or custom orders.
Tips for Finding the Perfect Island Burger
- Go local: Many restaurants highlight Island-raised beef and locally baked buns. Ask your server for details about sourcing if you're interested in supporting Vineyard farms.
- Time your visit: Some menu items are only available seasonally. Always check ahead for hours and offerings.
- Pair with local brews: Offshore Ale Company and Bad Martha Brewery in Edgartown both offer craft beer selections that pair perfectly with a hearty burger.
Final Bite: Your Best Burger Awaits
Finding your best burger on Martha’s Vineyard is a delicious adventure. Whether you’re searching for a simple, satisfying cheeseburger, a gourmet twist topped with lobster or Boursin cheese, or a plant-based option that doesn't sacrifice flavor, the Island has something for every taste. From Edgartown to Oak Bluffs and Vineyard Haven, the burger scene on Martha’s Vineyard is as diverse and delightful as the Island itself.