Looking for the best restaurants in Edgartown? This picturesque harbor town welcomes visitors with quintessential New England charm, scenic waterfront views, and an incredible variety of places to eat. Whether you're craving fresh local seafood, an elegant dinner overlooking the harbor, a cozy café for breakfast, a family-friendly restaurant, a local brewery, or homemade ice cream, Edgartown has something to satisfy every appetite. It's the perfect place to slow down, savor great food, and experience the welcoming hospitality that makes Martha's Vineyard such a beloved vacation destination.
Breakfast, Coffee, & Sweet Treats
Start your day with breakfast at Among the Flowers. Tucked away on charming Mayhew Lane, the café serves fresh pastries, breakfast sandwiches, omelets, smoothies, and shaded outdoor garden seating that captures the relaxed Vineyard lifestyle. Family-owned and operated and has offered friendly service to locals and tourists for 48 years. Dine among the flowers and experience for yourself what keeps people coming back to this little cafe’ with a big heart.
Another local favorite is Cozy Corner, where visitors enjoy homemade breakfasts, fresh coffee, baked goods, and friendly service before beginning a day of sightseeing. Owner Igor (Iggy) Vukoje idea is to make everyone feel welcome, as though they are in their own home. Originally from Europe, Iggy brings the charm of a traditional European coffee house to Edgartown.
Coffee lovers should not miss Espresso Love. Known for expertly prepared espresso drinks, specialty coffees, fresh pastries, sandwiches, and outdoor garden seating, it's the perfect place to recharge while exploring downtown. Open year-round, try “the Chilmark” made of freshly grilled chicken, havarti, basil pesto, tomato on fresh ciabatta bread.
No visit to Edgartown is complete without stopping at Mad Martha's Ice Cream. Famous throughout Martha's Vineyard, Mad Martha's serves generous portions of homemade ice cream in dozens of creative flavors that have become an Island tradition for generations of visitors.
Fine Dining in Edgartown
If you're looking for an upscale evening, Edgartown is home to several of Martha's Vineyard's premier restaurants.
19 Raw is one of the Island’s premier seafood destinations. Serving the largest oyster selection on Martha's Vineyard, the menu offers fresh and locally sourced ingredients, and, while focusing on seafood, there is a dish to suit every palate from steak to salad. It has become a must-visit restaurant for seafood lovers seeking an elegant yet lively atmosphere.
Just steps away, Alchemy Bistro & Bar has long been a favorite dining destination. Its creative New American menu features fresh seafood, premium steaks, handcrafted cocktails, and an extensive wine list served in a sophisticated yet welcoming setting. Their inspiration is soaked from the vibrant cultures and culinary styles of Spain, France and Italy, combined to create a unique American bistro experience.We believe in our history, which is why we
Inside the historic Harbor View Hotel, Bettini Restaurant combines coastal elegance with spectacular harbor views. Seasonal menus showcase locally sourced seafood, prime meats, and refined New England cuisine, making it an ideal location for anniversaries and special celebrations. The vibe is coastal chic with an elegant bar that draws a vibrant crowd of locals and island guests. Expansive windows reveal a magnificent coastal view that reinforces the kitchen’s relationship with the local landscape, creating a true island-to-table dining experience.
Nestled in “Nevin Square”, Detente is a favorite among food enthusiasts looking for intimate dining. Its inventive seasonal menu pairs beautifully with a fine wine selection. Since 2005, Kevin and Suzanna Crowell have been curating an atmosphere focused on relaxation, tranquility and thoughtfully prepared culinary creations.
The Dunes at the Winnetu combines a completely unique experience with their award-winning setting. Arrive in style on their water taxi through Katama Bay. Enjoy the relaxed dining with sweeping views and fresh coastal cuisine. The Dunes delivers an elevated Edgartown dining experience.
Casual Dining & Local Favorites
For a relaxed waterfront meal, The Wharf Pub & Restaurant serves fresh seafood, New England classics, steaks, pasta, and refreshing cocktails .It's a popular stop to “catch the game” or after a day of sightseeing and shopping downtown.
Just around the corner, Rockfish Bar and Grill offers a lively atmosphere featuring fresh seafood, burgers, sandwiches, tacos, and local favorites. Two newly renovated floors include a wood-fired pizza oven and two full bars in a casual upscale setting. Try their Lobster Pot Pie created with fresh lobster, onions, celery, corn and carrots and a creamy sauce topped with a flaky pastry crust.
Beer lovers should make time for Bad Martha's Farmers Brewery, where locally brewed craft beers are served alongside delicious food in a relaxed outdoor setting. Live music, family-friendly seating, and seasonal events making it an Island's favorite.
In the mood for a burger ? Then head to Wicked Burger on upper Main Street that serves up their “smashed burgers" as well as a crispy chicken sandwich and a special Children’s meal. Cool down with a creamy milk shake. As their motto says , “it’s gonna be wicked good”.
Open year-round locals and visitors alike gather at Town Bar and Grill MV. Bringing the comfort of a neighborhood pub they offer an expansive menu which includes fresh sushi, gluten free and vegetarian options.
Visitors looking for classic comfort food will appreciate the Edgartown Diner, a beloved local institution serving hearty breakfasts, homemade lunches, and traditional American favorites in a friendly atmosphere.The fifties themed diner is so authentically outfitted that you may feel like you have stepped back in time or onto the set of a movie where every detail has been thought through by a team of experts, right down to the soda fountain, the counter jukeboxes and the booths with Formica tops and vinyl two-toned benches. The Edgartown Diner is a real treat, even before you look at the menu.
For gourmet picnic supplies or an easy vacation meal, Edgartown Meat and Fish is an outstanding stop. Enjoy a fresh salad and sandwich or even freshly made sushi in the shop. They also carry fresh seafood, premium meats, prepared meals, sandwiches, salads, artisan cheeses, and fine wines, making it perfect for stocking your vacation rental or enjoying a beach picnic.
Wine Shops for Every Occasion
Edgartown is a wonderful destination for wine lovers and craft beer enthusiasts looking to discover something beyond the ordinary. Whether you're searching for a crisp IPA, a limited-release local craft brew, or the perfect bottle of wine to pair with fresh Martha's Vineyard seafood, the town's specialty liquor stores offer an impressive selection. Visitors can explore the extensive wine and rotating craft beer inventory at MV Wine & Spirits, or stop by Your Market for one of the Island's largest selections of wines, imported beers, and regional craft brews. Vintage Wine and Spirits is a boutique wine and spirits shop located on Winter Street. Shopping for dinner at Stop & Shop? Find the friendly service at Al's Package Store directly across the street. These locally owned shops feature knowledgeable staff who are happy to recommend wines for a beach picnic, a sunset dinner, or a special celebration, making Edgartown an excellent place to explore distinctive wines, small-batch spirits, and the best of New England's thriving craft beer scene.
Why Edgartown is One of the Best Dining Destinations on Martha's Vineyard
From award-winning seafood restaurants and elegant fine dining to charming cafés, family-owned diners, craft breweries, gourmet markets, and exceptional wine shops, Edgartown delivers one of New England's finest culinary experiences. Visitors can spend an entire day enjoying breakfast in a garden café, shopping along historic Main Street, sipping local craft beer, indulging in fresh oysters by the harbor, finishing with homemade ice cream, and selecting the perfect bottle of wine for a Vineyard sunset.
Whether you're visiting for a weekend getaway or an extended Martha's Vineyard vacation, Edgartown's diverse restaurant scene promises unforgettable meals that are every bit as memorable as the Island's beautiful beaches, historic architecture, and picturesque harbor.